Monthly Archives: October 2018

More equal than others?

Pigs graffitiWhy should we follow the principle that, when applying the Golden Rule, we should act so as to preserve, protect and promote the Golden Rule itself?

Well, if you subscribed to the Rule would you want others to preserve, protect and promote the Rule? Yes? Then you should preserve, protect and promote the Rule yourself.

This follows Publish and be damned as number 16 in a series of posts on the Golden Rule. The first was Any fool can make a rule.

Continue reading

Publish and be damned

International newspapers Rome 2005

© Stefano Corso 2005

Last time we suggested that someone following the Golden Rule would be faced with the impossible task of trying to please everyone. If so that would seem like a fatal objection to the Rule, whatever Confucius or Jesus might say.

This follows The miller, his son and the donkey as number 15 in a series of posts on the Golden Rule. The first was Any fool can make a rule. Next is More equal than others?

But perhaps again we are interpreting the Rule in a narrower way than the Rule itself would require.

Continue reading

Things

IMG-2537 copyIf you are in the neighbourhood the Museum der Dinge (‘Museum of Things’) in Kreuzberg, Berlin is well worth a visit. It boasts a huge and articulately presented collection of everyday objects of the 20th and 21st Centuries. The earliest Dinge I saw were from the First World War, but my pictures here are of what seem to be art deco artefacts from the Weimar period, plus a few rather more spooky memorabilia from a bit later.

© Chris Lawrence 2018.

Continue reading

Pietà

IMG-2520 660kb

Mother with her dead son

In the Neue Wache (‘New Guardhouse’) in Berlin is a copy of a small sculpture by Käthe Kollwitz. It stands beneath a circular open skylight, or oculus, which exposes it to the elements.

Kollwitz made the original in the late 1930s as a memorial to her son Peter who was killed in the First World War. In 1993 Chancellor Helmut Kohl commissioned sculptor Harald Haacke to make a considerably enlarged copy which was installed at the centre of the ‘Central Memorial of the Federal Republic of Germany to the Victims of War and Tyranny’ at the reopened Neue Wache.

© Chris Lawrence 2018.

The miller, his son and the donkey

Arrested French Resistance fighters, 1944

Arrested French Resistance fighters, 1944

Last time we suggested that value pluralism1 should only pose a problem for the Golden Rule if we apply the Rule simplistically, which the Rule itself should steer us away from. We will now consider another aspect which, ironically, could imply the Golden Rule might often be impossible to obey in practice, and particularly when we need it most.

This follows Value pluralism and the Golden Rule as number 14 in a series of posts on the Golden Rule. The first was Any fool can make a rule. Next is Publish and be damned.

Continue reading

Value pluralism and the Golden Rule

Symbols of nine world religions

How does the Golden Rule fare in an interconnected world made up of multicultural communities?

This follows Two big ideas as number 13 in a series of posts on the Golden Rule. The first was Any fool can make a rule. Next one is The miller, his son and the donkey.

Continue reading

Ifs and buts

Mourning angel, Florence

Mourning angel, Florence

This follows Payback time as number 11 in a series of posts on the Golden Rule. The first was Any fool can make a rule. Next one is Two big ideas.

What is ‘categorical’ about Kant‘s categorical imperative? This is to distinguish it from a hypothetical imperative, for example:

(i) If you want to (or have to) achieve y, then do x.

A categorical imperative would be simply:

(ii) Do x.

Continue reading

Payback time

Immanuel Kant

Immanuel Kant

This follows Once more without feeling as number 10 in a series of posts on the Golden Rule. The first was Any fool can make a rule. Next one is Ifs and buts.

It is now time to get to grips with Kant’s categorical imperative.

This will not be an exhaustive or comprehensive account. The focus will be on what kind of thing the categorical imperative is – its logical status, if you like.

Continue reading

Once more without feeling

Rabbits

Rabbits

This follows Conflict and compassion as number 9 in a series of posts on the Golden Rule. The first was Any fool can make a rule. Next one is Payback time.

We said last time that Kant did not want his readers to think his notion of duty – formulated as the categorical imperative – was just a rewrite of the Silver Rule (the Golden Rule in its negative formulation). He saw the Silver Rule as both banal and flawed.

Continue reading